Image Source: ESPN
Tommy Carr is set to make his first start for the Michigan Wolverines against No. 6 Indiana, marking a major moment for the freshman quarterback and a surprising turn in Michigan’s quarterback situation.
Carr, the grandson of former Michigan coach Lloyd Carr, earned the opportunity after delivering an impressive performance in relief against Penn State. His first start comes after Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham previously declined to announce which quarterback would lead the offense in the upcoming home game.
Tommy Carr Gets a Dramatic First Michigan Start
The freshman quarterback entered Michigan’s game against Penn State at halftime, with the Wolverines trailing 3-0. Carr replaced Bryce Underwood, who had started every game for Michigan since arriving on campus last year.
Rather than appearing overwhelmed by the pressure, Carr immediately provided stability and energy. He directed Michigan to three second-half touchdown drives, helping the Wolverines rally for a 21-18 victory over the Nittany Lions.
Carr’s most important play came with 2:58 remaining in the game. The quarterback broke free for a 12-yard touchdown run that helped seal the comeback win and showcased his mobility in a critical late-game situation.
That performance ultimately pushed Carr into the starting role against Indiana. The matchup presents a significant test, as the Hoosiers entered the game ranked No. 6 nationally.
A Surprising Shift in Michigan’s Quarterback Battle
Underwood’s move to the sideline represents a notable change for Michigan. The highly touted quarterback was the No. 1 overall recruit in the 2025 SC Next 300 and had been the Wolverines’ primary starter since joining the program.
However, his statistics this season have created concern. According to ESPN, Underwood has completed 58.1% of his passes and has recorded eight turnovers compared with seven total touchdowns. Those numbers opened the door for Carr to make his case.
For Michigan, the decision is about more than one strong half of football. The Wolverines must determine which quarterback can provide the most consistent production as the season moves deeper into conference play. Carr’s passing efficiency, decision-making and ability to extend plays could all factor into the evaluation.
At the same time, Underwood remains one of the program’s most talented young players. His experience as the full-time starter gives him valuable game knowledge, while Carr now brings momentum after a memorable relief appearance. The competition could become one of the most closely watched storylines surrounding Michigan football.
Carr’s Family Connection Adds to the Spotlight
Carr’s first start carries additional significance because of his family ties to major college football programs. He is the grandson of Lloyd Carr, who guided Michigan from 1995 through 2007 and won a national championship with the Wolverines in 1997.
Tommy Carr is also the younger brother of CJ Carr, the starting quarterback at Notre Dame. That connection has already drawn attention across the college football landscape, giving the freshman an unusual level of visibility for a player making his first career start.
Despite the spotlight, Kyle Whittingham praised Carr’s approach following the Penn State game. The Michigan coach described the quarterback’s performance as “smooth” and efficient, a strong endorsement after Carr was asked to enter a tense game with little time to prepare.
Those qualities will be tested against Indiana. A ranked opponent can challenge a young quarterback with defensive pressure, complex coverage schemes and the weight of a high-profile matchup. Carr’s response could influence Michigan’s offensive identity for the weeks ahead.
What Carr’s Start Means for Michigan
The decision gives Michigan a chance to evaluate Carr in a more complete role. One half of football offered encouraging signs, but a full start will reveal more about his command of the offense, accuracy and ability to handle adversity.
- Carr is making his first start for Michigan.
- He replaced Bryce Underwood at halftime against Penn State.
- He led three second-half touchdown drives.
- His 12-yard touchdown run helped secure Michigan’s 21-18 win.
- He is the grandson of Lloyd Carr and the younger brother of CJ Carr.
For fans, the Indiana matchup provides an early answer to whether Carr’s breakout relief appearance was the beginning of a larger quarterback transition or simply a timely spark. Either way, the freshman has earned an opportunity to show what he can do from the opening snap.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Tommy Carr?
Tommy Carr is a freshman quarterback for the Michigan Wolverines. He is the grandson of former Michigan coach Lloyd Carr and the younger brother of Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr.
Why is Tommy Carr starting for Michigan?
Carr earned his first start after replacing Bryce Underwood at halftime against Penn State and leading Michigan to a 21-18 comeback victory.
How did Carr perform against Penn State?
He led Michigan on three second-half touchdown drives and scored a 12-yard rushing touchdown with 2:58 remaining to help seal the win.
Who did Tommy Carr replace?
Carr replaced Bryce Underwood, who had started every Michigan game since arriving on campus last year.
Who is Michigan playing in Carr’s first start?
Carr is making his first start against the Indiana Hoosiers, who were ranked No. 6 at the time of the matchup.
