Former Pirates Player Urges Team to Trade Paul Skenes Before It’s Too Late

The Pittsburgh Pirates are under pressure to make critical decisions regarding their roster, particularly concerning star right-handed pitcher Paul Skenes. Recently, former Pirates player Erik Kratz weighed in on the situation, suggesting that the team should consider trading Skenes if they’re unable or unwilling to build a competitive team around him. This sentiment has sparked debates among fans and analysts alike.

Paul Skenes: A Once-in-a-Generation Talent

Paul Skenes has quickly emerged as one of baseball’s brightest stars. After being selected as the first overall pick in the 2023 MLB Draft, Skenes wowed spectators with his raw talent and skills on the mound. By the end of his rookie season, he had already clinched the prestigious title of National League Rookie of the Year and finished third in the NL Cy Young Award voting. Now, with an annual salary of just $875,000 in 2025, his value to the team and potential trade market has never been higher.

Kratz’s Perspective: Exploring Trade Opportunities

During a recent episode of the Foul Territory podcast, Erik Kratz emphasized the importance of utilizing Skenes’ market value. He described Skenes as “a chandelier in a haunted house,” a metaphor that illustrates the disparity between Skenes’s talent and the current state of the Pirates. If team owner Bob Nutting remains unwilling to invest in additional talent to make the team competitive, Kratz believes the Pirates should consider testing the waters with a potential trade.

Key Points from Kratz’s Argument

With Skenes’s potential to win 15 games per season, trading him might yield significant value for the franchise.
If the Pirates do not aim to invest around Skenes, it would be prudent to seek out trade opportunities to maximize returns.
Skenes’ contract allows for two additional pre-arbitration years, significantly enhancing his trade appeal.

While it seems counterintuitive to part ways with a burgeoning superstar, Kratz rationalizes that the Pirates could leverage Skenes’ immense trade value to start building a more competitive roster. The star pitcher’s ability to contribute to a contender could be a major factor in fetching substantial assets in return.

The State of the Pirates: A Team in Need of Direction

The concern among fans and former players alike stems from the Pirates’ struggles within the National League Central division. The organization has recurrently faced ups and downs, and the lack of a strong roster around Skenes raises questions about the team’s future. If Nutting is indeed indifferent to improving the competitive landscape, keeping Skenes may serve no purpose other than to waste a prime career.

Skenes’ Bright Future Ahead

Despite the uncertainty regarding his future with the team, Skenes’s potential continues to shine bright. The young pitcher remains under team control for several more years, presenting a unique opportunity for any franchise willing to embrace his talent. Teams across the league with playoff aspirations would likely view acquiring Skenes as a game-changing move.

The upcoming months will be crucial for the Pirates organization as they weigh their options. Their handling of Skenes, either through investment or trade, could set the tone for the future of the franchise. For now, the discussion ignited by Erik Kratz places Skenes at the center of attention, with many eager to see how it plays out in the evolving landscape of Major League Baseball.

Tags:

Paul Skenes, Pittsburgh Pirates, Erik Kratz, MLB Trade Rumors, National League, Cy Young Award, Baseball, Rookie of the Year, Sports News, Pirates Management