Image Source: Southern Living

Costco food court fans have a new mystery to solve after the warehouse retailer teased the return of a popular menu item. The company has not revealed what is coming back, but the announcement quickly prompted shoppers to share their best guesses online.

Costco posted the teaser video on Instagram Wednesday, Sept. 16. The short clip showed two people standing inside a Costco warehouse with their backs to the camera as they looked toward a food court menu.

Costco Food Court Teaser Sparks Excitement

In the video, one person says, “I think it’s going to look great right there.” The second responds, “I think so too. I can’t believe we’re bringing back BEEP for a limited time.”

The clip then cuts to a black screen displaying the words, “To be continued…” The deliberately vague message left the name of the returning item hidden, giving Costco members plenty of room to speculate.

Costco invited fans to guess what may be headed back to its food courts. While the company has not confirmed any of the suggestions, several familiar favorites quickly emerged as leading possibilities.

Fans Make Bold Guesses About the Menu Return

Among the items mentioned by Costco shoppers are:

Fries
The twisted churro
Costco’s famous combo pizza

The combo pizza has attracted especially strong interest. Before it disappeared from many Costco menus, the supreme-style pizza was known for its mix of pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, mushrooms, bell peppers and black olives.

Its removal sparked widespread disappointment among members, many of whom have continued asking Costco to bring it back. That history makes the combo pizza one of the most popular theories surrounding the latest teaser, although there is no official confirmation that it is the returning item.

What Costco Has Recently Added

The mystery comes as Costco continues to adjust its food court offerings. Earlier this year, the retailer quietly introduced a hot dog and bottled water combination. The $1.50 deal gives members the option to replace the traditional 20-ounce refillable fountain soda with a bottle of Kirkland Signature water.

The hot dog itself remained unchanged, preserving one of Costco’s best-known food court deals. The low price and familiar menu have helped the food court remain a major attraction for shoppers after warehouse visits.

Costco also expanded its chicken tenders meal nationwide in July after testing the option in select markets beginning in May. The meal costs $6.99 and includes five chicken strips and a dipping sauce.

Some influencers have compared the sauce to Chick-fil-A’s honey mustard. The addition gave members another substantial meal option alongside staples such as pizza, hot dogs and frozen desserts.

A Limited-Time Return Could Bring Back Loyal Fans

The wording of Costco’s teaser suggests that the returning product may be available only for a limited time. That could create urgency for shoppers who remember the item fondly or missed it after it was removed from the menu.

For now, Costco has provided no launch date, store list or official product name. The “to be continued” message indicates that another announcement may be coming, but members will have to wait for the retailer to reveal the answer.

Whether the mystery item turns out to be fries, a twisted churro, combo pizza or another discontinued favorite, the teaser has already achieved its goal: Costco shoppers are talking about the food court again.

Frequently Asked Questions

What item is Costco bringing back?

Costco has teased the return of a popular food court item but has not yet identified it. Fans are guessing fries, the twisted churro or combo pizza.

When did Costco post the teaser?

Costco posted the teaser video on Instagram on Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2026.

Is Costco bringing back the combo pizza?

The combo pizza is one possibility raised by fans, but Costco has not confirmed that it will return.

What new food court items has Costco added?

Costco recently introduced a hot dog and bottled water combination for $1.50 and expanded its chicken tenders meal nationwide for $6.99.

Will the returning item be available permanently?

The teaser specifically suggests the item may return for a limited time. Costco has not announced how long it will be available.